Labels are comforting, labels are familiar. They are convenient to define ourselves in a word. A snapshot of our identities. A quick and easy sign board to walk around the world with – so that we don’t have to stop and explain to people who we really are, by delving into a lifetime’s worth of experiences and histories. The backstories that we don’t have time to get into. The many many chapters that don’t always make logical sense. The changing world views. It’s simpler, easier to use labels – hello, I’m Pooja. I’m Indian. I’m a grad student, and all that it entails. I’m a Potterhead. An introvert. A bookworm, a nerd, a feminist. An obsessive planner. A city girl through-and-through. A vegetarian. A keyboard player. A summer girl. A dog person.
But each of these labels are all-or-nothing labels. If I’m not A, I must be Z. If I’m a dog person, I must dislike cats. If I’m a feminist, I must hate chivalry. If I love summer, I must be a winter-hater.
However, the world isn’t split into good people and Death Eaters, as Sirius Black so wisely says. I’m not one or the other. And neither are you. It’s so easy, so reassuring to put us in a little box – it feels comfortable and needs no further qualifiers, both for ourselves and for others. In the absence of labels, it takes time and patience to explain where we’re coming from, neither of which we necessarily have at any given moment.
Labels are all fine and dandy, but just as long as they’re just that – a first glimpse at a person. A guiding post of sorts. A little name tag that you stick on your shirt while walking into a roomful of strangers.
What happens when we give labels too much weight? When we rely on our labels just a little too much, and accidentally end up boxing ourselves in? I’m Indian, so must I staunchly keep my heritage alive, and never leave myself open to the ‘corrupting influences’ of the Western world? I’m an introvert, so should I just opt out of all group activities and parties? What if we end up boxing ourselves into a label – and even more terrifyingly: what happens when the label stops fitting, and we start feeling lost, feeling like an impostor?
Because these labels, you see, have been my identity all along. And if I’m not them anymore, what am I? I’m not A, but I’m not Z either. In a world of extremes, that’s pretty uncertain ground. What am I? Who am I? Where’s my one-word summary? What’s the excerpt on the back cover of my storybook? The short sweet concise description of who I am?
There are two ways of looking at this situation. Either I feel lost and bewildered, because I’m a weird hybrid who isn’t native to either place. I can flail about and try to pull myself towards one extreme. One clear identity. And I can constantly reject or dismiss hints of what doesn’t fit my unambiguous narrative.
Or: I could defy those pre-existing labels and define my own. Build my own middle ground. Stick on a new name tag for my current identity, with a bunch of empty name tags to leave room to evolve. I can be the person I am right now, even if it doesn’t totally make sense. My labels can be ‘95% vegetarian’ – to represent that I don’t seek out meat, but will eat chicken if all the veg options are tofu-based (ugh). An introvert, but one who won’t shut up when having a prolonged conversation with someone she’s feeling a connection to. An Indian who loves NYC and the freedom it grants her. A Potterhead who re-reads the seven books every year, but pretends that the Cursed Child never happened. A dog person who doesn’t mind the occasional snuggly kitten. A city girl who likes to lie down in grassy fields and count the stars. A summer -lovin’ sort who goes starry-eyed at the first glimpse of snow. A girly girl who loves romance and all things purple, but couldn’t care less about clothes shopping. I’m not a morning person, not a night owl – just a sleep person. I’m not Team Edward or Team Jacob – I’m Team WhyBella. A bookworm who occasionally gets sucked into the black hole that is Netflix, even though she has – gasp! – three unread books!
So there you go – that’s who I really am. I’m the middle ground, my own unique middle ground. I’m neither extreme. Absolute labels are not enough to define me. Or you. We are too human, too complex for labels. We cannot be summarized in a single word. We are so much more than a clean concise excerpt at the back of our books. We are colorful and messy and constantly evolving. We define our labels – they don’t define us!